Dec
28
2008

How can Wikipedia work when anyone can just change anything?

Change (photo by Meanest Indian - CC-BY)

Change - Damage - Decay (photo by Meanest Indian - CC-BY)

It’s truly remarkable that Wikipedia has become a valuable reference work. After all, it is the end result of hundreds of millions of uncontrolled edits by anyone who wants to click the “Edit” link. How can it work? Why has Wikipedia not decayed into a wasteland of propaganda, delusions and spam?

For sure, there are occasional temporary instances of vandalism, and a small number of pages are riddled with inaccuracies or garbled nonsense, but for the most part Wikipedia’s pages are informative and useful. Every day Wikipedia becomes more comprehensive and, on the whole, more reliable.

The key to Wikipedia’s success is that, on average, each edit is more likely to make Wikipedia better than to make it worse. Even if only 51% of edits were improvements, over a long period of time they would overcome the 49% of edits that were undesirable.

In reality, the percentage of “good” edits is much higher than 50%, and so the quality and reliability of Wikipedia has improved steadily and rapidly.

An important mechanism is the ability for any person to revert (undo) another person’s edit. It’s so easy to revert an edit that the effort required to vandalise an article is much greater than the effort required to repair that vandalism. Since only a tiny proportion of users are vandals, the long-term change is overwhelmingly for the better.

Despite this, there are a few tiny pockets of persistent vandalism. Pages on abortion, drugs, politics and religion are likely to suffer repeatedly. Here, and only here, Wikipedia brings to bear some more tools – the ability of administrators to temporarily lock a page or ban a user.

It is interesting to ponder whether Wikipedia’s experiment in mass participation could be applied to other aspects of society.

Related questions:

  • What was Leptis Magna?What was Leptis Magna? Leptis Magna was a prominent city of the Roman Empire. Its ruins are located in Libya and is one of the most unspoiled Roman ruins in the Mediterranean. The city was founded by […]
  • What are the disadvantages of URL-shortening services like TinyURL?What are the disadvantages of URL-shortening services like TinyURL? A link-shortening service works like this: you give it a long, unwieldy URL like www.example.com/pagegen.asp?c=01x78bf9&y=tyfalt918x and it gives you a simple URL like […]
  • How does the Creative Commons CC0 (CC-zero) license work?How does the Creative Commons CC0 (CC-zero) license work? Every country has a notion of the public domain—where creative and scientific works older than a certain age are available to everyone as part of humanity's shared culture. But what if […]
  • How can I get my question answered at Quezi?How can I get my question answered at Quezi? Do you need an answer to a question? You can post just about any question at Yahoo Answers, and you'll probably get an answer. Whether it will be a good or lousy answer we really […]
  • How does a Ponzi scheme scam work?How does a Ponzi scheme scam work? All Ponzi schemes are based on maintaining the illusion that profits are being generated, when the "profits" are really new money being invested into the scheme. Therefore, the Ponzi […]

  Need research? Quezi's researchers can answer your questions at uclue.com

Written by | 3,178 views | Tags: , , ,

No Comments

Comments are closed.

RSS feed for comments on this post.


Privacy Policy | Acknowledgements