May
15
2009

Is it true there was once a female pope?

Basilica of St. John Lateran

According to legend, a Pope Joan was on her way to the Basilica of St. John Lateran (pictured above) when she gave birth to a son. Ivan.kopvac photo. CC-BY.

It’s an enticing tale: A precocious girl, Joan, growing up in the 9th century in Mainz, Germany, disguises herself as a boy so she can learn Greek and Latin at a monastery. She, still dressing as a male, eventually makes her way to Rome, where under the name of John she becomes the secretary to a cardinal. Impressed with her/his knowledge, the cardinals in 855 A.D. eventually appoint Joan-as-John the pope. But her reign doesn’t last long; in her third year as pope, Joan has become pregnant, and she ends up giving birth during a papal procession, and thus her secret is discovered. Depending on which tale you believe, Pope Joan and her baby are stoned after being drug by a horse, or she was sent to a convent where she raised her son, who eventually became a bishop.

The only problem with the story is that there’s no compelling evidence that it is true. It is little more than an urban legend, apparently spread not as a story of women’s empowerment or cleverness, but as a way of ridiculing the papacy or as a warning to women that they shouldn’t step outside their place.

Even so, you can go to Rome today and find supposed evidence of her existence — paintings, sculptures, ancient documents — even Vicus Papissa, the street where she supposedly gave birth. There are even old papal thrones with a hole in the seat, supposedly used so that cardinals could verify future popes’ manhood and prevent such a mistake from happening again. To this day, the purpose of the seat design is unknown.

The story was believed in many circles for centuries. The problem for historians, though, is that there are no contemporary documents even suggesting that there was such a person as Pope Joan. The earlier document comes from about 200 years later — but the notation about Pope Joan was not in the original scribe’s handwriting and probably was not written until centuries later. Although there are said to be about 500 ancient documents that mention or allude to Pope Joan, they generally were written some 400 years after her death. In light of how many enemies the papacy had during this time period, it is hard to imagine the critics not seizing on the story of Pope Joan centuries earlier if she had in fact existed.

Furthermore, the historical record is clear that there were no three-year gaps in the papacy where Pope Joan could have served. Benedict III became pope almost immediately after the death of Leo IV. There just wasn’t time for some rogue pope to have held the office for as long as Pope Joan supposedly did.

Even today the story gets attention, as a German-produced movie on Pope Joan is in the works. So why has the legend survived for so long? Part of the answer has to do with what makes many urban legends persist: We all like to heard about the rich and the powerful being bamboozled, and this story is a classic in that regard. Also, many urban legends are at least remotely plausible to those who know some of the facts — the papacy was nothing in the 800s like it is today, and more than one man acceded to the papal throne despite a history of scandal, so this tale might seem like just another in a series of papal shenanigans common to the era.

Related questions:

  • When was Jesus born?When was Jesus born? Although much of the world celebrates Christmas on Dec. 25 as the supposed birthday of Jesus of Nazareth, and our calendar is based on the assumption that year-counting began the year of […]
  • What is a simultaneum?What is a simultaneum? The Latin word simultaneum can refer to the simultaneous occurrence of unrelated events, but when it came into use in the 16th century it had—and still has—a specific meaning, […]
  • When and where was Barack Obama born?When and where was Barack Obama born? Months after Barack H. Obama became president of the United States, Internet rumors continue to circulate that Obama is not a natural-born citizen of the United States and is therefore […]
  • Who were the Vestal Virgins?Who were the Vestal Virgins? The Vestal Virgins were the only female priests within the Roman religious system. The head of the college of Vesta was called the Virgo Vestalis Maxima, and she was under the direct […]
  • Who were the Etruscans?Who were the Etruscans? Etruscan civilization evolved in northern and central Italy about 800 BC.  This era gave way in 7th century BC to an increasingly orientalizing culture that was influenced by Greek […]

  Need research? Quezi's researchers can answer your questions at uclue.com

2 Comments

  • john birkin says:

    Well this story fascinates me at least, most interesting!

    Will look forward to the movie on the subject

  • Larry says:

    I wonder if those “papal thrones” were a solution for incontinence or simply to avoid the pope’s having to succomb to mere human needs during long services or council meetings. Indeed, they are described as such:
    “The sedes stercoraria (defecation seats)”
    Wikipedia on “Pope Joan”, which has much more information.

RSS feed for comments on this post.


Privacy Policy | Acknowledgements